Reply as the business the customer chose: acknowledge the problem, apologise, say what you did and what has changed, and leave the supplier out of it. Settle the supplier's share privately, then fix the process.

A review about something you did not do

The part came from the manufacturer with a fault. The order sat at the supplier's warehouse for an extra week. The courier left the box in the rain.

Then the review arrives, and it names your business. One star, a paragraph about how you let the customer down, and nothing about the company that actually caused it.

The first instinct is to set the record straight in the reply. It is understandable, and in public it almost always makes things worse.

From the customer's side the supplier does not exist. They chose you, paid you and trusted you, and they are right to hold you to it.

Why blaming the supplier backfires

The second is the one owners rarely think about. A reply meant to clear your name tells everyone reading that the same thing could happen to them, and that you will explain it away when it does.

Who reads the reply

The customer who wrote the review may never read your answer. Everyone deciding whether to hire you will.

Those readers are not judging who caused the problem. They are judging what happens when something goes wrong, because sooner or later something goes wrong in every business.

A reply that takes responsibility, puts things right and explains what changed answers their real question. A reply that assigns blame answers a question nobody asked.

What the reply should say

Keep it short, and keep it in this order.

Acknowledge the specific problem in plain words: the delivery was late, the part failed. Apologise, and leave out the but that usually follows.

Say what you did or will do for this customer, if anything is still outstanding, and invite them to contact you directly, by name.

Then say what has changed so it does not happen again. That sentence is written for the readers, and it is the most persuasive line in the reply.

Owning it without pretending

Taking responsibility does not mean pretending you made the part or drove the truck.

You can describe the cause without naming anyone: a part we installed failed within weeks, the order reached us too late to check. That is honest, and it keeps the attention on what you did about it.

What to leave out is detail that sounds like a defence: invoice dates, the supplier's name, the shipping record.

If a warranty claim is involved, keep the reply general and settle the details in private. A public reply is not the place to work out who pays for what.

A worked example

A tuxedo rental shop in the old downtown of a small city measures wedding parties in its fitting room and orders the suits from a rental supplier's warehouse, which ships them in the week of the wedding.

In August one groomsman's jacket arrived in the wrong size on the Friday before a Saturday wedding. The shop found a replacement in its own small stock, but in a slightly different shade, and it showed in every photograph.

The groom's mother left a one-star review about the mismatched jacket. The owner's first draft of a reply explained that the warehouse had sent the wrong size and that the shop had done its best with what it had.

The reply that went up instead apologised, described the problem in one sentence and said the shop had refunded that rental.

It added that every suit now arrives by the Wednesday before a wedding and is tried on by Thursday, leaving time to replace anything wrong.

The owner claimed the cost back from the supplier privately, and wrote the earlier delivery date into the shop's standing order instructions.

The review stayed up. Beside it, couples now read that the shop checks every suit days ahead.

Fix the process, not just the reply

A reply handles one review. The change to the process is what prevents the next one.

Most supplier problems reach customers through the same gaps: no buffer before the date goods are needed, no check on arrival, no spares of common items, and no early warning to the customer when a hold-up is known.

The last is the cheapest to fix. A customer told on Tuesday that a part is late is disappointed. A customer who finds out on the day writes the review.

Write the change down, and make it someone's job.

Settle it with the supplier privately

The supplier's share of the problem is a business matter, not a public one.

Tell them what happened and what it cost you, in writing, and ask for the cost back where your agreement allows it. Keep a short record of each incident.

If the same supplier keeps causing the same problem, that record is what lets you decide calmly to change, rather than after one bad weekend.

Set expectations on the website

Some of these reviews can be prevented before anything goes wrong.

If delivery depends on a supplier, say on the website how long orders usually take: six weeks before the wedding for suits, say, or a week or two for special-order parts.

A customer who was given the timetable plans around it, and is far less likely to blame you for it.

The counter-case

There are times when the cause matters in public, though rarely the supplier's name.

If a review makes a claim that is wrong and damaging, such as a safety allegation, a short factual correction is reasonable, still without blaming anyone else.

And when the customer hired the other company directly, as with a subcontractor they chose themselves, saying so plainly and politely is fair.

Otherwise, reply as the business the customer chose, fix the process, and settle the rest in private.

The next review like this

  1. Wait an hour before replying.
  2. Acknowledge the problem in plain words.
  3. Apologise with no excuses attached.
  4. Say what has changed so it will not recur.
  5. Leave the supplier's name out of it.
  6. Claim the cost back privately, in writing.
  7. Close the gap that let it reach the customer.

Step four is the one readers remember. It turns a complaint about the past into a promise about the future, which is what someone deciding whether to hire you is looking for.

How a reply can become the problem itself is covered in a review response that was itself the problem.

Frequently asked questions

Should I say the supplier caused the problem?

Not in public. It reads as an excuse, tells future customers you depend on someone unreliable, and changes nothing for them. Settle the supplier's share privately.

Who is the reply really for?

The people deciding whether to hire you. They are judging what happens when something goes wrong, not who caused it, and they will read every word.

What should the reply include?

An acknowledgement of the specific problem, an apology with no excuse attached, what you did for the customer, and what has changed so it does not happen again.

Can I describe the cause at all?

Yes, without naming anyone: a part failed, an order arrived too late to check. Leave out details that sound like a defence, such as dates, names and shipping records.

How do I stop it happening again?

Build a buffer before the date goods are needed, check deliveries on arrival, keep spares of common items, and tell customers early when a hold-up is known.

What should I do about the supplier?

Tell them in writing what happened and what it cost, claim the cost back where your agreement allows, and keep a record of each incident.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

A review blaming you for a supplier?

Forward the review and the reply you had in mind. We will suggest wording that owns the problem without blaming anyone.

Start a Conversation